Real impact of sugar taxes on soft drinks

Original article published by Beverage Blog - Tuesday 22 January 2019

I have argued against taxing added sugar in soft drinks, because I think it deflects attention from real solutions to obesity. Am I wrong ? The latest evidence backs me up.

A new global assessment has come this month from Geoff Parker, who is Chief Executive Officer of the Australian Beverages Council. He reports that:

  • The New Zealand Ministry of Health analysed 47 studies and “found the impact of such taxes on public health was weak.”
  • In Mexico, “what actually happened according to tax receipts … was a very small decline … of less than 2 per cent in the first year, … a recovery in sales in year 2 … and growth in sales thereafter.”
  • In Berkeley, California, calorie intake from beverages increased because of people switching to smoothies and juices.
  • In Britain, there hasn’t been “any discernible impact on consumer behaviour.”

He concludes that “this intervention lacks evidence from anywhere in the world that such a tax has a measureable impact on obesity rates and analysis has shown it doesn’t improve diets either.”

Instead, there have been multiple adverse unintended consequences including job losses, budget shortfalls and cost pressure on lower income households.

He calls for greater collaboration between governments and industry, with an emphasis on reformulation and smaller pack sizes.

Then, of course, there is the rest of our diet…

 

 

Comments

 

Go back

Contact us

  • Forename
  • Surname
  • Telephone
  • Email
  • Company
  • Your message
  • How did you hear about Zenith Global?
  • Please specify how if 'Other'

Please leave us a message and we will be happy to answer any questions you may have.

Zenith Global Ltd
7 Kingsmead Square
Bath
BA1 2AB
United Kingdom
UK tel: +44 (0) 1225 327900
US tel: +1 (404) 372 2758

Like most other business websites, we use ‘cookies’ to track usage and enhance website functionality. You are welcome to opt out or give your consent by continuing without changing this setting.

Change settings Continue

Find out more about Cookies